literally, nothing exclusionists do, and nothing you say to an exclusionist, will ever matter. nothing will ever get a response beyond “nuh uh!”
they’ll phrase it different ways every time: “aces are cishet. cishets are cishet. they just wanna be oppressed so bad. they’re literally not oppressed in any way. they don’t experience homophobia or transphobia. they benefit from homophobia and transphobia. they are lying. that never happened.
“you can’t use their tumblr posts as proof. you can’t use studies about them as proof. you can’t use every real-life org including them as proof. you can’t use our community’s own oral history as proof. you can’t use our community’s own written historical documents as proof.
“lmao i’m not a terf, i’m literally an nb lesbian. lmao i’m not quoting terf rhetoric, i’m literally an nb lesbian. lmao i’m not consistently attacking trans women inclusionists, i’m literally an nb lesbian. lmao our movement isn’t full of terfs, we literally called out a terf once. lmao how dare you show me a blocklist of hundreds of terf exclusionists to call out, I’m literally an nb lesbian.
“anyway the community literally started to combat homophobia and transphobia. anyway it’s always been lgbtpn. anyway it’s always been lgbt. anyway cishets aren’t lgbt.”
some of the things that canonically Don’t Even Matter and are clearly Fake News:
(Same study: A higher percentage of trans aces are harassed at work than of trans LGBQ people. A much higher percentage of trans aces have had to quit school because of harassment, than of trans LGBQ people. A higher percentage of trans aces have experienced family rejection, than of trans LGBQ people. A higher percentage of trans aces lack health insurance, than of trans LGBQ people.)
I had no idea about any of these facts. Have so far tried not to get involved but according to these stats it’s a lot more important than I thought
honestly, getting involved in Discourse is probably pointless. It seems like the only exclusionists left are people who are so invested in their beliefs that they can’t or won’t even look at other information; they just insist everything’s all lies, and make fun of it without reading.
But getting involved in supporting aces in whatever ways they need/want, or raising awareness among the rest of us? That’s always worth doing. 💖
i was talking to my bi ace genderqueer cousin about this and pulled up the post again and like….
i just want to highlight this part. This list is all from the National Transgender Discrimination Survey, which had a sample size of something like 15,000 people. Which is fucking huge for that type of study.
A higher percentage of trans aces are harassed at work than of trans LGBQ people.
A much higher percentage of trans aces have had to quit school because of harassment, than of trans LGBQ people.
A higher percentage of trans aces have experienced family rejection, than of trans LGBQ people.
A higher percentage of trans aces lack health insurance, than of trans LGBQ people.
None of this is because we are trans. If it were because we were trans, then the numbers would be similar to the numbers in the other groups. The difference between the groups is that we’re ace.
I need to point that out, because I’m pretty sure the knee-jerk exclusionist reaction to this would be “but they’re trans, so it is just because they’re trans.”
And it’s not a surprising difference. It parallels what happens when studies of things like suicide, poverty, et cetera, in gay+bi vs straight people, actually separate out the gay and bi people. It always turns out that the bi people have the highest rates of whatever is being studied.
This is just the same thing happening again. The groups that get the least attention have the worst outcomes, gosh gee I wonder how that could be… and then that makes it harder for us to advocate for ourselves, which continues the vicious cycle.
basically, a lot of exclusionists have seized upon Pride Month as a great time to double down on claiming that “aces aren’t oppressed in any way”
this list is my gift to everyone who sees those posts and has to be like, “I mean, we might not die or be kicked out or assaulted for being ace, but that doesn’t mean it’s easy” or “so we should take a backseat, but we deserve to be in the car”
print it out, crumple it into a ball, and throw it at an exclusionist today!
If you think of asexual as “not having a sex drive,” then you’d probably be surprised to learn that aces used to be a part of the bi community.
But if you think of it as “not having a sexual orientation,” then it might suddenly become clear.
Because in a world where so many people only ever think of, or mention, “gay or straight” as possible orientations, there’s not that much difference between “not having a sexual orientation” and “not being either gay or straight.”
When the question is only framed as “which of these opposite points does your arrow point to,” I don’t feel like there’s a huge difference between your answer being “point???????” or “arrow???????”
Ohhh, everything makes sense now (says the bi ace)
SWEEET
Which is I think why a lot of aces identify as bi or pan at some point in their lives before landing on “asexual.” If you know you’re not gay or straight, there’s much more awareness of bisexuality than of asexuality, so it makes sense that people would end up there by default.
Yes! And if you were coming out 20 oror more years ago, there was basically zero awareness of any other things.
this perfectly describes my late teens, most of which I spent convinced I was bisexual because I was equally attracted to men and women. Thing is, I actually wasn’t attracted to either, and I thought that that weird uncomfortable feeling I got each time something was overly sexualized was because I wasn’t used to feeling lust and/or arousal, and those new urges were making me uncomfortable, instead of just being plain uncomfortable with sexualization. I didn’t even know that asexuality was a thing until I read about it in a fanfic a year ago.
Chiming in as another aro/ace person who identified as bi for a couple years before realizing the ace spectrum existed. The poster right above me pretty much describes exactly my thought process. Basically, it went:
I’m not gay, and I’m definitely not straight, so I must be bi, because I find people of many different genders attractive (notice i say find attractive, not attracted to). I chalked my icky-squirmy feelings when thinking about sex and to a lesser extent relationships up to lack of experience as I’ve never been in a relationship or even been on a date.
But then in the past year or two I finally learned about asexuality and one night I had this huge emotional revelation when things just clicked suddenly.
So yeah, until recently, bi is where i fit best, and where i felt most accepted.
Up until now I thought “ace ppl were bi/pan?? that makes no sense????’
But reading this I remember–I thought I was bi/pan too!! When I was in high school, I thought I was romantically attracted to men nd sexually attracted to women (I knew almost nothing about gender). I didn’t know about split-attraction so I was horrified of being some kind of freak and doomed to be alone and/or unhappy, to say the least.
People get all offended and insulted and furious about how aces identified as bi/pan, but you need to understand: I only did so because I didn’t know/think asexuality was an option. I wasn’t gay, I wasn’t straight. What else could I be?
At 15, when I was just starting to use the internet to learn about sexuality I came across this: “Bisexuality is the ability to reach down someone’s pants and not care about whatever you find.” And that was, I thought, the closest thing I could find about how I felt.
You might be thinking, “But this is such a wild contradiction to what asexuality is! How could you possibly be bi/pan?” In my experience at least, the logic was something like, “Being bi/pan is an attraction to all genders, but I don’t experience attraction to two+/any gender. Which is similar in that I’m equally indifferent to multiple/all genders. They cancel out, or something? I’m romantically attracted to men, sexually to women, they cancel out?”
When you don’t know what asexuality is, you’re going to come to some conclusions that may make no sense at all to someone else. And they might not make sense to you, either. But what choice do you have? You have to be SOMETHING, or so we’re taught.
And then once I realized I wasn’t REALLY bi or pan, I chose not to identify as anything, since no labels fit me. I thought it would be freeing, not having to worry about labels. But god, it was so lonely. Here I was, some kind of anolomy, brimming with so many questions and no answers. And this is why asexuality is an orientation, rather than a lack of a sexuality. Ahaha, high school was misery in terms of finding my sexuality.
I don’t know, does this make sense to anyone? It’s hard to explain, at least for me.
“I’m nothing” eventually became a common response for me as well.
and gee, I wonder if the feeling of “I’m nothing” contributes to the higher rates of suicidality for a-spec people, like bi erasure does for bi people
for that matter, I wonder if the double whammy of “what I am doesn’t exist” and “what I think I am doesn’t exist”, of bi erasure and the even worse ace erasure, does too
and by “I wonder if” I mean “I bet that….”
I relate so fucking much about everything said in this post. I also identified shortly as bi, then pan, before landing on the “nothing” phase, that made me feel like such a worthless human being. Finding out about asexuality was both a terrifying and liberating experience. It was hard at first coming to terms with it for me, but when it did happen there was this humongous feeling of relief, that I was normal
So when I first found out that asexuality was a part of the bisexual community before splitting up, it made a whole lot of sense already to me. It was pretty logical.
this is why i keep both. idk if i’m attracted to everyone or no one. nor do i need to know. both words together are my orientation. and i love it!
honestly we owe so much to lesbians and bi women who stepped up when gay and bi men were barred from being w their partners in hospitals or were ill themselves .
its sadly rarely mentioned even in lgbt spaces how these women gave so much and weren’t even asked they just did it
many old dykes that I have known have told me about their experiences during the AIDS crisis – most specifically, the terror and bystander trauma experienced by the lesbians who worked tirelessly delivering medication and meals to those men confined to their apartments. my retired lesbian professor struggled to teach the crisis, the genocide, because of this – the tens upon tens of times where she would arrive at an apartment only to push open the door and find a close friend dead on the hardwood floor, days left neglected. the times where she arrived at empty apartments because landlords were mass-evicting their gay tenants, never to hear from those men again. the times where she had to manually hold her friends’ jaws open just to get water down, the bodies she bathed, the men she loved who were violently stolen from her life, watching as gay mens’ families left their children to die in complete isolation rather than accept their sexuality. these women are still alive, these women carry the legacy of all the men lost, these women care an invaluable lesson of solidarity, love, and bonds that cannot be broken by any act of oppression, violence, or illness. reach out to them, talk to them, let them know you see their pain and you appreciate them.
As someone with fibromyalgia severe enough to have me on a walker or bed-bound, it took ten years (beginning about age 15) for diagnosis because I was told I was being dramatic or just needed to try harder. In that time, with no alternative, I worked and suffered through numerous intense manual labour jobs.
Because I didn’t listen to my body, I have long term damage that can’t be repaired. I was only taken seriously when I ended up in hospital for a week about two years ago. It should not have had to go that far.
I’m telling you, one spoonie to another:
“Push through the pain,” isn’t an option when your body trying to tell you something.
Chronic pain (even without a diagnosis) is real and serious and needs to be treated as such. I hear you, I believe you.
my best friend is autistic & her mom is forcing her to go on a gluten-free diet and take a ~magic pill~ (falsely advertised probiotic) called the All Star Probiotic to cure her autism. what the fuck what the fuck what the fuck
i can drop the link to the site if anyone wants to see how fucked up it is but basically the site claims that gut health is directly related to brain health and because people on the spectrum generally have gut problems (not mentioned: the fact that those gut problems are usually due to sensory issues with food affecting their diet) and this pill will fix the gut problems. it never directly claims it’ll cure autism but it’s pretty heavily implied, and all the reviews make me physically ill.
here’s a couple screenshots from the site i still have on my phone
there’s no links to or even mentions of research studies anywhere on the site as far as i’ve found. i am on the spectrum and have been offered these by my best friend’s mom several times. please please spread that a gluten free diet is not going to cure autism (it’s been shown there’s a correlation with GLUTEN SENSITIVE autistic kids not having EXTREME meltdowns but that’s all, and it hasn’t even been proven) and there is no magic pill cure, nor does there need to be.
this makes me so unbelievably upset. normally i like to see a mix of opinions on my posts because it exposes me to other beliefs and helps me develop my own ideas on things, but if you in any way think that any part of this- “this” being trying to cure a child’s autism by forcing them to take internet pills or making them keep a diet that’s causing them physical stomach pains and other discomfort they weren’t experiencing to any degree before- is fine or acceptable behavior as a parent or other legal guardian, don’t ever interact with my blog again.
basic science: if we’re not in pain from our gluten sensitivity or intolerance, WE WILL HAVE LESS ISSUES
but if we are NOT celiac or gluten sensitive
THIS WILL DO NOTHING
YOU CANT CURE AUTISM, IT IS HOW YOUR BRAIN HAS BEEN PERMANENTLY WIRED
THAT’S LIKE TRYING TO TURN A CAT INTO A DOG
IT DOESN’T WORK
you can abuse it and dress it up as a dog, and train it to mimick a dog
BUT IT IS STILL A CAT
so ABA, and pulling shit like this to try to ‘normalize’ and ‘cure’ your child?
YOUR KID IS STILL AUTISTIC
YOU’RE JUST A SHITTY PARENT
Pretty much.
I am one of the autistic people with adult-diagnosed celiac. This quack stuff is extra disturbing, the way it manages to harm both autistics and people with actual autoimmune conditions at the same time.
You must be logged in to post a comment.